 |
Infinite Energy Device Update
New Energy Research Laboratory
Device and Process Testing Update
Published in IE Volume 4, Issue #24
Conducted by Ed Wall and Gene Mallove
July, 1999
Work on the Ohmori-Mizuno plasma electrolysis
exploration cell sent to us for testing by NRG, (Nova Resources
Group), (see IE No. 23) has continued. We have focused on the "detritus"
produced--the substance found at the bottom of the cell after running.
It is collected by filtration and is found to have properties that
could loosely be described as "ferromagnetic." When thoroughly
dried and spread out on paper, a magnet under the paper will affect
the pattern that the substance forms, much like iron filings will
do, only not as strongly (see photo below). Perhaps this is not
ferromagnetism but paramagnetism. Whatever the explanation, there
is no doubt that the effect is fully repeatable. Powdered "virgin"
pure carbon rod (Alfa-Aesar, nominally < 5 ppm Fe) used for the
electrodes will not do this.
 |
| Figure
2. NRG cell before use. Note much larger anode (right) than
cathode area. Attached silver coin was used for neutron detection
(none were detected). |
We had the detritus tested for eight metals by an
outside testing laboratory (Granite State Analytical, Inc. of Derry,
New Hampshire). The results from two test series indicated a weak
presence of iron (0.60 mg/l in the filtrate, 0.01% and 0.03% by
weight in the detritus, 0.0% and 0.02% by weight in the virgin carbon
rod). Noteworthy in our second test series is a strong presence
of calcium, both in the detritus and the filtrate, but not in the
rod--for which we know of no conventional source (other than possible
impurity in the K2CO3 electrolyte, which has not yet been tested).
We are certainly mindful that a few cold fusion researchers claim
to have found transmutation of K to Ca. See the second series results
tabulated below (Table 1).
The problems with possible contamination are foremost
on our minds, so this work is only preliminary, except for the magnetically
active detritus, for which we are seeking a conventional explanation.
Colleague Michael J. Schaffer commented to us: "Many materials
are magnetic. Ferromagnetism requires unpaired electrons plus sufficient
coupling to align all the spins of neighboring atoms in the same
direction. The former is a common property and gives paramagnetism,
a relatively weak, but measurable magnetic response. Spin alignment
is a much rarer phenomenon and is what turns weak paramagnetism
into strong ferromagnetism... You might just have a magnetic compound
of K and C and O."
 |
| Figure
3. When thoroughly dried and spread out on paper, a magnet
(see inset) under the paper causes bristling in the detritus. |
We are also studying the energy balance of the
cell by examining the steam condensate that is collected and comparing
that with input electrical energy. An inherent uncertainty exists
in measuring power into an arcing load, because the spectrum of frequencies
is extremely broad. The best method would be to use a high sampling
rate digital oscilloscope, which can multiply voltage and current
(voltage collected across a shunt resistor) at each sampling interval.
Unfortunately, we do not yet have such an instrument However, we used
our Amprobe DM-II Power Analyzer on the AC (60 Hz) power input to
the rectifier that provides the DC power to drive the cell. Harmonic
analysis of the oscillographs of that sinusoid reveals a very minor
portion of the power contained in harmonics that would not be measured
accurately by this device. Even if input power is measured accurately,
there are losses in the rectifier. Also, heat and intense light radiated
from the cell and plumbing are not reflected in the quantity of condensate
collected--nor is the energy of any hydrogen gas that may be produced
accounted for. That is why the NRG-developed cell comes with a heater
for a comparison with pure joule input power vs. condensate. On a
few attempts using it, we found that, like the electrolysis cell,
it has top lid leaks that need fixing.
Second
Series of Test Results
(Earlier Results were not as complete)
|
|
|
Detritus
Sample #6
1.6031 grams
|
Alfa-Aesar
Carbon
Rod #2
1.0203 grams
|
| Iron |
|
0.03%
|
0.02%
|
| Chromium |
|
0.00%
|
0.00%
|
| Calcium |
|
0.47%
|
0.16%
|
| Potassium |
|
5.76%
|
0.62%
|
| Aluminum |
|
0.10%
|
0.09%
|
| Magnesium |
|
0.08%
|
0.04%
|
| Copper |
|
0.00%
|
0.00%
|
| Manganese |
|
0.00%
|
0.00%
|
|
|
|
|
Liquid
Filtrate Analysis
(approx. Vol. 500 ml)
|
|
Concentration |
Total
Amount
|
%of
2.5gm of
exposed Cathode
|
| Iron |
0.60
mg/l
|
0.300
mg
|
0.0120%
|
| Chromium |
0.11
mg/l
|
0.055
mg
|
0.0022%
|
| Calcium |
229
mg/l
|
114.5
mg
|
9.1600%
|
| Aluminum |
4.23
mg/l
|
2.115
mg
|
0.0850%
|
| Magnesium |
3.50
mg/l
|
1.750
mg
|
0.0700%
|
| Copper |
0.09
mg/l
|
0.045
mg
|
0.0018%
|
| Manganese |
0.03
mg/l
|
0.015
mg
|
0.0006%
|
|
|
|
|
|
The condenser, a copper pipe jacketed by a larger
PVC pipe in which cold water circulates, works well. Very little
condensate collects on the inside walls of the condensate collection
jar. Initial checks were made for pH of the condensate to be sure
that it did not contain electrolyte by determining that it measured
pH=7.0. We were excited to find some extraordinary quantities of
what were initially assumed to be pure water condensate on some
high power runs. Re-running the test determined that its pH 9.2
was, quite contaminated with electrolyte. The solution had blown
past a long portion of uphill tubing with plastic mesh that is designed
to "de-mist," then through a longer uphill piece of tube
to enter the top of the condenser. The jury is still out on the
cell's energy balance.
Hydrosonic PumpTM Preparations
The Griggs machine sits quietly in
the corner, now wired with two thermocouples each on input and output
and plumbed for operation. We are waiting on final details of approval
from the power company before we can operate it.
Dennis Cravens-Dennis Letts Cell
The assortment of devices under test here at
NERL is increasing. We recently purchased a Pons/Fleischmann-type
heavy-water, closed cell from Dennis Cravens that he and Dennis
Letts have worked on together to investigate the high-frequency
RF (82 MHz) electromagnetic stimulation of a Pd cathode. Dennis
Letts reports recent success in boosting the DC excess energy of
such a cell with 82 MHz RF of insignificant power. We are in the
calibration and cathode loading stages of this investigation.
The flow-calorimetry system employs a stainless steel
Dewar within a larger tempering beaker. The cell under test rests
in the Dewar and is tightly wrapped with a copper coil. The Teflon
cap of the cell seals the contents and has a recombiner built into
it. Cooling water that runs through the copper coil also runs through
the tempering beaker, a peristaltic pump, a pulse damping device,
and an electronic flowmeter. A reservoir is provided, which allows
for easy periodic checking of the flow rate using a graduated cylinder
and a stop watch. As with most experimental devices, this one has
many subtleties. Dennis Cravens warns us that we have to think very
carefully about how heat travels when assembling the device, for
it is packed in insulation that should not get moist. Moist insulation
can act as a heat wick.
The tempering beaker serves to provide a stable environment
for the Dewar. It has a thermostatically controlled heating pad
wrapped around it to maintain a 30ûC water temperature. This
is a large, stable thermal mass for measurement stability.
Catalytic Fusion Cell of Dr. Les Case
Work has continued in attempting full-calorimetric
measurement on a catalytic fusion cell of Dr. Case's design. We
have obtained a new WW-II oxygen cylinder cell from him, but have
encountered measurement problems with the present set up (see IE
No. 23). We will be revising
it.
|